An IRS proposal ties private schools' tax exemption to race-neutral scholarships by Mid-2027.
The proposed rule has 2,637 posted public comments, the Mellon Foundation's among them. It would also change the rules for scholarship funds and the donors behind them.
By The Editors · The Game of Giving
A proposed Internal Revenue Service rule would take away the tax exemption of any private school, college or university that considers race, color, or national or ethnic origin "for any purpose," including in scholarships. The public comment period closed on November 3, 2026, and by November 11 the federal docket showed 2,637 posted comments.
The rule, numbered REG-119986-25 and titled Racial Nondiscrimination in Private Schools, was published in the Federal Register on September 4, 2026. It would apply to schools' taxable years beginning after May 31, 2027, and the Treasury Department and the IRS have scheduled a public hearing for December 2, 2026. The Mellon Foundation, which made its comment public on November 9, has asked the IRS to withdraw it.
What would the rule change?
It would turn an old IRS policy into a regulation and remove an exception. Since 1971, in Revenue Ruling 71-447, the IRS has held that a private school with a racially discriminatory policy toward students does not qualify as a charity. The Supreme Court upheld that position in Bob Jones University v. United States in 1983.
What is new is the reach. The proposed rule adds a section to the tax regulations, numbered 1.501(c)(3)-2, saying a private school is not operated exclusively for exempt purposes if it "adopts, maintains, or enforces any policy or practice" that discriminates on the basis of race, color, or national or ethnic origin in any educational, admissions, scholarship, loan, athletic or other school program, and that this includes policies that do so "for any purpose." The preamble says the rule applies "regardless of the intent behind or the legality of such discrimination," naming remedial and diversity goals as examples.
It would also delete three sentences from Revenue Procedure 75-50, the IRS's guidance for private schools since 1975. Those sentences say that programs, scholarships and loans favoring racial minority groups do not count as discrimination when their purpose is to promote a school's nondiscriminatory policy. With them gone, a scholarship limited to students of one race or ethnicity would put the school's exemption at risk.
Who would it cover?
Private schools of every level, but not public ones. The definition covers any 501(c)(3) educational organization, meaning private primary and secondary schools, colleges, universities and professional or trade schools. Government-run schools are excluded.
Religious schools keep one specific protection. The preamble says a school may still select students by religious affiliation, and that doing so is not racial discrimination just because members of a faith share ancestry, as long as the criterion is religion alone.
The IRS's own estimate of the reach rests on old data. It says the rule may affect 18,000 tax-exempt private schools and 750,000 students who may qualify for scholarships based on race, ethnicity or national identity. The footnote behind the student figure cites a Government Accountability Office survey published on January 14, 1994, nearly 33 years ago, because, the IRS says, it does not collect information on race or ethnicity. It also says it has no way to count the donors who give to race-based scholarship funds.
How many people commented, and when?
Most of the comments were posted in two waves, one in September and one in the last days before the deadline. We pulled the posting counts from the regulations.gov docket, IRS-2026-1189, on November 11.
| Posted | Comments | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Before October 13 | 1,093 | 41% |
| October 13 to October 27 | 220 | 8% |
| October 28 to November 4 | 1,319 | 50% |
| November 5 to November 11 | 5 | Under 1% |
| Total | 2,637 | 100% |
Posting dates lag the date a comment was sent, and agencies do not always post every submission, so the count is a floor. In the first 2,000 records we downloaded, 381, about 19%, were filed anonymously. Most named commenters were individuals. The organizations we found by name included the American Council on Education, the NAACP, the Legal Defense Fund, the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, the Association of Christian Schools International, the National Association of Charitable Gift Planners, the North Carolina Center for Nonprofits and dozens of individual Lutheran, Catholic, Quaker and independent schools. We have not read every letter, and the docket titles alone do not show which side each one takes.
What did Mellon argue?
That the rule goes beyond settled law and would chill legal activity. In its November 3 comment, summarized in a statement dated November 9, the foundation said the rule's uncertainty "will almost certainly chill otherwise lawful conduct and speech," turning almost any academic center, course, scholarship, student group or program related to race into "a potential gamble risking the school's tax-exempt status." It warned that the effect could reach charities outside higher education.
The IRS's case, in the preamble, rests on the Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard, which struck down race-conscious admissions at Harvard and the University of North Carolina. The agency argues that because colleges have already changed admissions since that ruling, the main effect on them will fall on scholarship and loan programs.
What schools and scholarship donors can check now
None of this is final, and it is not legal advice. But the proposed timeline gives schools until their first taxable year after May 31, 2027, and the work of reviewing a scholarship portfolio takes time. In our view, a business office or development team can start with four steps.
- List every scholarship, prize and loan fund whose eligibility mentions race, color, ethnicity or national origin, including old endowed funds.
- Pull the gift agreement for each. Many restricted gifts have a clause for changed circumstances; if not, changing the terms can require the donor's consent or a court. We explained why in a restricted gift is a promise you have to keep.
- Talk to living donors before the rule is final, not after.
- Brief the board. Losing an exemption is a board-level risk, and as we wrote about another route to that outcome, three missed filings can end a charity's exemption with no warning letter.
Separately, a Senate-passed bill would give charities a guaranteed IRS appeal when they lose their status; it still needs a House vote. The next date on this rule is the December 2 hearing at 10 a.m. Eastern. The IRS said it would hold it only if someone submitted an outline of testimony by November 3, and at least one comment in the docket is labeled as a request to testify. A final rule would follow, which the agencies expect to publish before May 31, 2027.
General information for donors and nonprofit leaders, not legal or tax advice. How we report is set out in our editorial guide.